

The KPI Snapshot Fallacy: Why You Can’t Lead from a Single Frame
By Adam Chickman May, 26 2025
Imagine you’re watching a movie.
But instead of watching it play out, you’re handed one random still frame.
In the image, a man is running.
Is he chasing someone?
Running from danger?
Training for a marathon?
Late for dinner?
There’s no way to know — because you’re not seeing the full story.
You’re just seeing a single moment, stripped of the context that makes it mean something.
And yet…
That’s exactly how most companies look at their KPIs.
The Snapshot Problem in Revenue
You’ve heard this in meetings:
“We generated 50 MQLs last month.”
“Win rate is 27%.”
“ASP this quarter is $14.3K.”
Great. But… compared to what?
-
Was the MQL goal 50, or 100?
-
Was win rate 32% last quarter? Is it trending up or down?
-
Is that $14.3K deal size high for your space — or leaving money on the table?
Without context, these metrics are just data points.
They’re still frames in a much longer story.
And when you make decisions based on a snapshot?
You risk reacting to a moment — instead of leading from the full narrative.
Every KPI Needs a Story Arc
To understand if a number is good, bad, or dangerous, you need to ask:
-
📊 Compared to Plan
-
What did we intend to hit?
-
-
🕰 Compared to the Past
-
Is this trending better or worse?
-
-
🏁 Compared to Peers
-
What does great performance actually look like for companies like ours?
-
50 MQLs might be world-class — or a warning sign.
You can’t know unless it’s grounded in these three dimensions.
What Happens Without Context?
You overreact. Or worse, you under-react.
-
Marketing celebrates 50 MQLs — but the target was 100.
-
Sales worries about win rate — but it’s up 4 pts quarter over quarter.
-
You chase last quarter’s ASP — without realizing your segment benchmark is 20% higher.
Leaders without context make uninformed decisions.
They fix the wrong things, double down on the wrong trends, and overlook the biggest opportunities.
The Best Revenue Teams Don’t Look at Snapshots — They Read the Film
They don’t just look at a number.
They ask: What does this mean in the broader story we’re telling this quarter?
They read every KPI through the lens of:
-
Plan — what we said we’d do
-
Past — what we’ve done before
-
Peers — what best-in-class looks like
That’s how they know where they stand.
That’s how they decide where to focus.
And that’s how they avoid being misled by single-frame thinking.
Where This Gets Hard (and Where Most Teams Break)
Of course, in theory this all makes sense.
In practice? It’s difficult.
-
It’s hard to compare every KPI against plan — especially when the plan is buried in a spreadsheet.
-
It’s hard to look at past performance trends when you’re juggling 9 tabs just to get last quarter’s numbers.
-
It’s nearly impossible to benchmark against peers unless you’re constantly doing outside research.
So what happens?
Even smart teams fall back to snapshot thinking.
It’s easier. But it’s riskier.
What the Best Practice Looks Like in Action
Imagine if every time you looked at a KPI, you saw this:
“50 MQLs created this month — 12 below plan, down 8% from last month, 27% below peer benchmark. Estimated impact: –$185K if trend holds.”
Now you’re not reacting to a number.
You’re responding to a story.
And you know what to do next.
That’s Why We Built RevdUp
RevdUp doesn’t just show you KPIs — it audits and contextualizes every one:
-
Against your plan
-
Against your past
-
Against your peer benchmarks
-
And most importantly, by revenue impact
So you’re not staring at snapshots anymore.
You’re seeing the whole story — and what it means for your number.
Because great revenue leaders don’t guess what a KPI means.
They’re handed the context.
And they act with clarity.
No guesswork. No overreaction. Just the next best decision.